A week ago we reported on the June 28
National Review article by Robert VerBruggen (article
here) revealing important new evidence supporting what we have long contended: that Professor Laurence Tribe has for years run a ghostwriting mill in which his books and articles (including his career-making constitutional law treatise) are drafted for him by his current and former students, with Tribe serving mostly as a compiler of material written by others, not as an actual "author" of the works bearing his name.
One of our most important posts on this point, dated Feb. 2, 2006, discussed an essay by Dean Lawrence Velvel touching on our "ghostwriting mill" description of Tribe's method of producing books. See
here. In particular, we quoted Dean Velvel's comment that a law professor he knows had recently told him that while a student at Harvard Law School he had been asked "to work on
American Constitutional Law" and "he knew several people who had done so. . . . The people who had worked for Tribe, said this professor, had written large tracts of Tribe's treatise."
As we mentioned last week, we first learned of the
National Review article from one of the
Harvard Parody bloggers. They ended up doing a lengthy video (which we provided significant help with), explaining in detail the Larry Tribe ghostwriting/plagiarism scandal which Dean Elena Kagan was instrumental in whitewashing, entitled:
"I'm Larry Tribe": The Story Behind the Parody. The end of the video includes highly entertaining audio, photos, and lyrics of the 2005 live performance of the "I'm Larry Tribe" parody skit. (If you want to watch only the skit, it's available as a discrete clip on YouTube,
here.)
The full video is posted at the
new Harvard Parody site on WordPress.com (which apparently has video hosting capabilities not available on the
old Harvard Parody platform).
[7/12 update: a reader suggested we embed the video; here it is]
[7/15 UPDATE: In case you have difficulty viewing the Harvard Parody videos, either as embedded on this blog or at HarvardParody.wordpress.com, the videos are also posted on YouTube on the Harvard Parody channel, here:
http://www.youtube.com/user/harvardparody]
One final point. In response to our post of last week, "R.O. Denver" e-mailed us about the new evidence of plagiarism by Tribe discussed in the
National Review article, of which he had quite detailed knowledge. Denver was the law professor who tipped off the
Harvard Crimson to new evidence of plagiarism by Charles Ogletree in 2006. See
here. Denver immediately supplied us with very helpful background information (particularly on the research assistant singled out by Tribe) which we used in helping put together the video. Denver recently informed us that he plans to launch a website (similar to the one he created on the new evidence of Ogletree's plagiarism, see
here) setting forth that background information and fully documenting the new evidence of plagiarism by Tribe, complete with images of the relevant pages of Tribe's treatise and of the sources which were copied into Tribe's treatise. We greatly appreciate his assistance, which will minimize our burden in keeping this blog up to date. We will post a link to his website once it is available.